PTC staff says gas cart ban may be tough to enforce

Ban to be considered at Thursday PTC council meeting

A proposal to ban nearly all gas-powered golf carts in 10 years, and halt the registration of newly-purchased gas carts sometime next year, will be considered Thursday night by the Peachtree City Council.

The latest version of the ban would not be enforced on disabled drivers who have a valid disabled parking permit; also, golf cart dealers who rent gas golf carts would be allowed to get new decals over the next 10 years as they replace their rental fleet.

The ban would forbid any gas-powered golf cart from being registered after 10 years, but currently-owned gas carts would be grandfathered until that date.

However, there is a significant concern from city staff about the ability to enforce the ban, as state law “prohibits any inspection relating to the registration of carts, making it impossible to verify whether a person registering a new cart has an electric or gasoline powered cart,” according to a memo to council authored by city staff.

The proposed ban has been a source of wide-ranging debate. Some citizens have favored the ban, citing the foul odor and noise emitted by gas-powered carts. Others, however, have argued that the unlimited range of a gas golf cart is particularly useful to families and the elderly who depend on them for their only means of transportation.

About 5 percent of the city’s registered golf carts are gas-powered, leaving some to argue that there isn’t much of a problem with gas carts to begin with.

Golf cart dealers who rent carts have said they cannot rent electric carts because of the possibility that when the charge runs out, their clients will become stranded.

Further concerns about enforcement from staff include:

• The police department has no way to verify whether a gas-powered cart with a valid decal was registered before or after the ban went into effect;

• Staffing levels will restrict the ability to verify the ongoing validity of disabled permits; and

• The ban may not address citizen complaints about gas-powered carts, which typically come after the July 4th holidays when dealers are renting a high volume of gas-powered carts. The city exempts cart registration requirements during the holiday and the amendment exempts rental carts, “so the most common cause of complaints will still be authorized under the ordinance,” according to the memo.

At an August council meeting, Councilman Eric Imker said he thinks golf cart technology will be dramatically improved in 10 years including better batteries to provide a longer range. At that meeting Imker said he supported the ban, along with Councilman Doug Sturbaum and Mayor Don Haddix.

Councilwoman Kim Learnard, who did not support the ban, said she wanted to hear information about such technology before the ordinance was adopted, and said she was extremely concerned about the potential for a negative impact on the city’s tourism and local businesses.

Councilwoman Vanessa Fleisch, who also opposed the gas golf cart ban, said the ban would devalue gas golf carts currently owned by residents.

Fleisch went so far as to call a gas cart ban “an unwanted government intrusion into our lives.”

SPQR
SPQR's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/15/2007
smelly cart smelly cart

So who is the the connected busybody that has decided that gas carts have to go and has managed to escalate a non problem into a current burning issue using a totally bogus survey? Let's see. We won't even bother including this in the official survey sent out in January(another really really bad idea). That might backfire because we suspect most people are ambivalent( don't give a rat's a**) about the whole topic. So we'll have a special survey just for gas golf carts. The logic being that only people that have strong feelings on the topic will bother to respond. So if only 5% have gas carts what we are really going to see is a subset of the gas cart 5%( a very small minority) against all those supporting a ban ( a much larger minority). The vast majority of the citizens don't weigh in because they don't care one way or the other. By conducting a survey like this that pits a very small minority against a larger minority the outcome is preordained beyond a doubt. The term railroaded comes to mind. Also, keep in mind the survey has no honesty safeguards. It is truly amazing the way Staff and the Mayor quote this survey as if it is valid. They are either very naive or think we are very stupid.

Mike King
Mike King's picture
Offline
Joined: 11/29/2006
Just Wasting Time...

...is all this council is doing at the behest of the Mayor and those 'valued' surveys of his.

I have to believe Mudcat was right, Peachtree City would have fared much better with an all female council.

SPQR
SPQR's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/15/2007
M.K.

The losing Lady is a little bit of a my way or the highway type but at this point beginning to look better every day!

Recent Comments