Judge rules Starship sold prohibited items; owner says they're not toys, but 'novelties'

An Aug. 5 ruling by Coweta County Chief Magistrate Jim Stripling found the Starship Adult Novelties and Gifts store on Ga. Highway 34 at Thomas Crossroads in violation of the county obscenity ordinance. Starship attorney Alan Begner said he will appeal the ruling and potentially file a constitutional challenge in Coweta Superior Court.

Starship opened its Coweta store in late 2010. An obscenity ordinance adopted by the Coweta County Commission just before the store received a business license prohibits the use of sex toys unless the devices are for a bona fide medical, scientific, legislative, judicial, law enforcement, scientific or educational purpose.

At issue was the county’s contention that Starship was distributing devices used primarily for stimulating genital organs. Though the store has been open for nearly three years, Coweta County attorney Nathan Lee on Thursday said the action was taken now because issues relating to Starship had been in constant litigation since the ordinance was enacted.

From his perspective and pertaining to the conditions for sale, Begner said Starship was not selling the items for non-privileged reasons, adding that the items are also sold as novelties, which is not illegal. Begner noted that the state law prohibiting the sale of sex toys was struck down in 2006.

Stripling in his ruling concluded that Starship had violated the obscenity statue, imposed a fine of $205 and stated that the store should cease selling the items.

Begner is appealing the decision, effectively stalling the ruling until the matter is decided in Coweta County Superior Court.

Begner on Thursday said he did not bring up a constitutional challenge of the county’s obscenity ordinance in magistrate court. But that might change, Begner added.

“If we win the appeal the county can leave us alone or go after us,” Begner said. “If they go after us or if we lose the appeal, I’m preparing a constitutional challenge to the Coweta County ordinance that will be filed in Superior Court.”

A move by Coweta County in early 2010 to deny Starship a business license was reversed in Coweta County Superior Court.

NUK_1
NUK_1's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/17/2007
Coweta...2 steps forward and one step back

Seriously, the fundies there are out of their heads. The $200 fine pretty much represents the waste of time of the alleged offense/trial and the judge did all he could to simply interpret the law as written and not be an activist for either side. It's been appealed as is the whole poorly-written and rushed ordinance that tried to keep the store from ever opening in the first place.

The judge is trying to give the county a way out of this mess without the county looking like a bunch of fundie-goofs as they have ever since Starship was planned to open, ordinances suddenly drawn-up after the fact, and direct heat put on the clerk to not approve their business license.

Give it a rest, fundies. Don't you have something better to do? After watching you picket the store when it was a vacant building in the middle of a thunderstorm, I guess you don't.

Lot of positive things happening in Coweta right now. This ain't one of them.