Man, 22, killed by deputy, called 9-1-1 threatening hostage

UPDATED Monday, Aug. 6, 11:30 a.m. — The man who was shot to death by a Fayette County sheriff's deputy after holding a friend hostage at knifepoint early Saturday morning has been identified as Joseph Evitts, 22, of 207 Buckeye Road,

Fayette sheriff's officials said Evitts held a knife to the 17-year-old victim's throat and refused to drop the weapon prior to the shooting. Evans was struck in the head, since that was the only part of his body not obstructed by the victim, according to GBI Special Agent in Charge Wayne Smith.

Smith said Evitts and the 17-year-old were at the home of Evitts' grandmother when the incident occurred, but the GBI probe is focusing on whether the officer followed state law in taking the life of Evitts. With the investigation nearly concluded, "there is no indication at this point of any wrongdoing," Smith said.

Smith declined to name the 17-year-old hostage or the name of the sheriff's deputy who fired the shot. The results of the investigation, including the autopsy and toxicology results will be forwarded to the district attorney's office once the probe is complete, Smith said.

Smith said that Evitts and the victim were friends and had planned on going fishing later that day.

The 9-1-1 call that sent deputies scrambling to the home on Buckeye Road was chilling, as Evitts himself called 911 and said: “You’ve got 12 minutes to get here before I kill him.”

Within minutes, Evitts was dead, killed by a single bullet to the head from a Fayette County deputy sheriff, who had no choice but to fire to save a 17-year-old named Cody from having his neck slashed.

Those details come from a family friend of Cody’s, who is on medication at his home, still in shock at the tragic turn of events that began with a night of friendly drinking at Evitts' home on Buckeye Road in north Fayette County.

The Georgia Bureau of Investigation is probing Evitts' death, standard procedure in an officer-involved shooting. The Fayette County Sheriff’s Department is saying nothing beyond a GBI-approved news release Saturday morning that gave no names of anybody involved. This update includes unofficial information from a family friend who knew both men.

According to the family friend — who wished to remain publicly unidentified — here’s what happened:

The younger Cody got a call Friday night from his friend Joe. The 22-year-old said he was depressed and wanted Cody to come to Evitts' home on Buckeye Road.

Joe Evitts was drinking heavily but the visit was friendly up until a single moment “when something snapped in Joe.”

As the two were relieving themselves off the back porch, Evitts started beating Cody, according to the family friend. Both Evitts and Cody are described as “big boys,” meaning neither was small in stature.

At some point during the struggle, Evitts called 9-1-1 and warned the dispatcher to get officers to his house within 12 minutes or he was going to kill Cody.

The first deputies to arrive found Evitts astride Cody, holding a knife to Cody’s throat. Cody suffered two lacerations and a cut mark across his throat, the family friend said.

Deputies shouted several times at Evitts to drop the knife, but Joe disregarded the warnings, the friend said. “The deputy had no choice,” the friend said. “He had to shoot.”

With Evitts still astride Cody on the ground, one deputy fired one pistol shot, striking Evitts in the head and killing him instantly.

Cody was treated at a hospital and released.

The family friend said that Cody was still in shock. “These two were friends, I know both of them. Cody was in my house a few days ago. I saw Joe Tuesday night. This is a tragedy.”

Here’s the Saturday news release from the sheriff’s department:

“On Aug. 4, 2012 at approximately 3:35 a.m. Fayette County Sheriff’s Office deputies responded to a fight in progress call at a residence on Buckeye Road in north Fayette County.

“When Fayette deputies arrived at the incident location they encountered a 22-year-old male suspect holding a 17-year-old victim hostage with a knife to the victim’s throat. The suspect refused to drop the deadly weapon even after the victim and a witness at the scene say the Fayette deputies ordered him multiple times to do so.

“Fayette deputies were forced to utilize deadly force by discharging their duty issued firearm and firing a single shot striking the suspect. Fayette County EMS responded to the scene where the suspect was later pronounced deceased.

“It is common practice for the Fayette County Sheriff’s Office to request the Georgia Bureau of Investigations (GBI) to handle all officer involved shootings. This case is currently under investigation by the GBI.”

=======================================

FIRST PUBLISHED ONLINE STORY — A Fayette County deputy shot and killed a man early Saturday morning after a fight ended in a hostage standoff on Buckeye Road in north Fayette County.

A 22-year-old unidentified man was holding a 17-year-old hostage with a knife to the throat and refused to drop the knife after being warned “multiple times,” said Sheriff’s Investigator Brent Rowan in an emailed news release.

A deputy — so far unidentified — fired a single shot and killed the 22-year-old.

The status of the unidentified hostage was not disclosed.

Here’s the news release from the sheriff’s department:

“On Aug. 4, 2012 at approximately 3:35 a.m. Fayette County Sheriff’s Office Deputies responded to a fight in progress call at a residence on Buckeye Road in north Fayette County.

“When Fayette deputies arrived at the incident location they encountered a 22-year-old male suspect holding a 17-year-old victim hostage with a knife to the victim’s throat. The suspect refused to drop the deadly weapon even after the victim and a witness at the scene say the Fayette deputies ordered him multiple times to do so.

“Fayette deputies were forced to utilize deadly force by discharging their duty issued firearm and firing a single shot striking the suspect. Fayette County EMS responded to the scene where the suspect was later pronounced deceased.

“It is common practice for the Fayette County Sheriff’s Office to request the Georgia Bureau of Investigations (GBI) to handle all officer involved shootings. This case is currently under investigation by the GBI.”

SPQR
SPQR's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/15/2007
Bi Polar

used to call it manic depressive. For every crime there is a victim . This guy was probably easily identified as potentially dangerous.Don't mess with people that have draconian mood swings.

moelarrycurly
moelarrycurly's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/17/2010
Alcohol and Depression

now there is a recipe for disaster. Tragedy all the way around. Even for the deputy who had to do his job and did it admirably.

hijoshm
hijoshm's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/16/2008
Great job!!!

Great job!!!

taxed too much
taxed too much's picture
Offline
Joined: 07/15/2012
We the People ..

We have had enough! We The People are sick and tired of the criminal element. Sick of those who think they are above the law, sick of those who live off "We the People" via government..not just for short term help, but for generations. Many of those who abuse government assistance for generations seem to defiantly and blatantly ignore the law and law enforcement. God Bless the law enforcement of Fayette County and thank you for helping to keep us safe. Criminals beware and take your lawlessness elsewhere.
PS I hear from my friends at the Probate Court that Weapons Carry License are flying off the shelves!

Spyglass
Spyglass's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/28/2008
Good work

IMHO

ptctrader2010
ptctrader2010's picture
Offline
Joined: 03/06/2010
Good job Deputy

From the face of this report, you did exactly what you were trained to... Use deadly force only when the threat to you or another is life- threatening and imminent.

And... when you drew your weapon, it was to kill the perp. As per training.

Good job. Our prayers to you as you deal with this tragic event. Remember there could have been a different, more tragic outcome.

Just wondering
Just wondering's picture
Offline
Joined: 07/19/2012
How hard hearted to rejoice

How hard hearted to rejoice over ANY death! We should offer prayers for the deputy, the suspect and all those who love either of them.

WakeUp
WakeUp's picture
Offline
Joined: 03/14/2006
Just wondering

if you would rejoice if the deputy freed you from the hostage situation.

taxed too much
taxed too much's picture
Offline
Joined: 07/15/2012
Good Job Deputy

My prayers go out to the deputy. I truly believe that most law enforcement officers never want to pull their weapon but when they do, training and preparedness is critical. It continues to amaze me that some criminals refuse to listen and obey orders from armed law enforcement. Oh well, one less "piece of crap" alive.

MWF
MWF's picture
Offline
Joined: 02/01/2006
Prayers for Deputy

Yes, pray for the deputy. Pray that the family of the 22-year-old will not hold a press conference announcing a lawsuit against the department and the deputy. If the deputy had not taken action and the 17-year-old had died, a lawsuit would be filed by the family of the hostage because he did not take action to save his life. People do not realize how difficult it is for law enforcement. Either way you go, someone is going to file a lawsuit and stress your family out for a couple of years while it all plays out. Even if what you did was right, they will make you look wrong in the media.

kcchiefandy
kcchiefandy's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/18/2009
3:35am.

Give you 100-1 odds drugs and/or alcohol were involved.

AtHomeGym
AtHomeGym's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/18/2007
KCCA & Drugs

Speaking of drugs, how do youlike 'conscious sedation'??

kcchiefandy
kcchiefandy's picture
Offline
Joined: 09/18/2009
Actually, AHG...

...I was completely knocked out! I remember joshing w/ the Doc & nurse, then getting up in to a wheelchair to a recovery area; was driven home by wife, took a nap, and was right as rain that evening! Looks like I'm good for 10 more years!

AtHomeGym
AtHomeGym's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/18/2007
KCCA & Results

Good news! Yep, the whole ordeal just knocks you for a loop the rest of the day but recovery comes quick!