Todd, Key grade sup’t., BoE majority with fiscal ‘F’

‘We should have made the tough decisions to cut more, close more, do more months ago ... The biggest cost savings can be realized by closing under-utilized schools ... The board did not follow the community imperative. We are now reduced to fiscal crisis management.’ — Bob Todd & Marion Key

Fayette County Board of Education members Bob Todd and Marion Key have drawn a line in the sand. In a letter to the editor in this week’s edition, the two board members said budget cuts during the past two years amounted to “too little, too late” and that deep, strategic cuts for next year must be made to protect the school system.

Todd and Key said the letter is in response to community questions about their having voted against the adoption of the school system’s 2012-2013 budget in June. It was a budget that came with $177 million in expenses and $163 million in revenues and used nearly all of the school system’s remaining $15 million fund balance to balance it. The budget was adopted on a 3-2 vote, with board members Terri Smith, Janet Smola and Chairman Leonard Presberg in favor and Key and Todd opposed.

The budget adoption left approximately $800,000 in the projected fund balance as of June 30, 2013. Key and Todd in the letter noted that a total of $26 million in fund balance has been used to balance the budgets in the past two years. Now with essentially nothing left to fall back on for next year the school board is faced with millions in additional cuts, they said.

“Due to a significant financial crisis, the FCBoE is at a crucial point — a point where tough decisions must be made to ensure the fiscal viability of our education system. Unfortunately, this year’s budget — for the second year in a row — pulls millions of dollars from the system’s financial reserves. This is akin to paying expected monthly household bills with savings intended for a rainy day,” the letter said.

“The glaring question is, why is this being done for the second year? The answer is that the new superintendent(Jeff Bearden) came on board in January of 2011 and proposed using $11 million of reserves with the understanding that a plan to cut expenses and reduce this use of reserves would be presented to the board in the fall. This never happened.”

A part of the resolution to offset falling local property tax dollars and falling state revenues from decreasing student enrollment should come with the closure of some of the school system’s schools, Key and Todd suggested. Fayette has opened five new schools since 2002. Yet today the enrollment level, which is projected to fall through 2021, is back to what it was in 2001.

“The reality is that we are a year behind in our decision-making — we should have made the tough decisions to cut more, close more, do more months ago,” the letter said. “The biggest cost savings can be realized by closing under-utilized schools. The community understands this. In the 2011 community survey, the respondents preferred closing schools to cutting programs and services to students, but the board did not follow the community imperative. We are now reduced to fiscal crisis management.”

The community survey referenced by Key and Todd was taken by the school system early last fall. Included in the survey was the idea of closing one unnamed middle school and two unnamed elementary schools.

The idea of closing the middle school had the agreement of 35.9 percent of respondents while 27.3 percent disagreed. Of those unsure, 21.9 percent leaned toward closure while 14.9 percent likely preferred the school remain open.

Another topic, that of closing two unnamed elementary schools and opening Rivers Elementary, found more agreement than disagreement. Approximately 40 percent of respondents agreed with closing the schools and 19.3 percent were unsure but probably agreed. On the opposite side, 30.6 percent disagreed and 10.3 percent were unsure but probably disagreed.

There were a total of 5,413 responses to the survey, with 21.4 percent being the parent of an elementary student, 16.5 percent being the parent of a middle school student, 17 percent being the parent of a student at a different level and 11.6 percent were community members with no children in the school system. Beyond that, 26.1 percent of respondents were employed by the school system.

Bearden, after the survey and earlier this year, recommended that Fayetteville Intermediate School, Hood Avenue Primary and Fayette Middle School be closed next year and that Rivers Elementary School located northwest of Fayetteville be opened.

All three schools are in Fayetteville, and student numbers at all three are majority black: Fayette Middle at 59.5 percent, Fayetteville Intermediate at 58 percent, and Hood Avenue at 54.8 percent black.

The topic at a recent board meeting ended with Bearden being instructed to return with proposals that would also include the closure of Tyrone Elementary and/or Brooks Elementary schools. Both Tyrone (at 63.4 percent) and Brooks (at 82.2 percent) have predominately white populations.

Todd at the meeting also suggested that Inman Elementary be closed but the idea got no traction.

At Bearden’s recommendation, the school board in June agreed that the process to determine which schools to close would begin in late summer and would be up for a vote in December. The closure of each school would amount to a savings of approximately $800,000.

It was the idea of closing the schools in Brooks and Tyrone that had parents at the school board meeting after the 2011 survey concluded. They took the position, and still do today, that the small schools constitute an integral part of their communities.

Key and Todd agreed, though they also noted the cost of running those schools in the face of falling revenues is financially questionable.

“Overhead costs are similar at every school, regardless of the number of students. Every dollar spent on unneeded overhead costs drain resources from the classroom. To illustrate, the current per pupil cost for overhead operating expenses at Brooks is $2,711. It is $2,312 for Tyrone and would be $1,061 for a consolidated Hood/Fayette complex,” they said.

Todd and Key said the criteria for determining school closures should be capacity, enrollment, the proximity of desk space in nearby schools and, potentially, the physical condition of the school.

Bearden’s initial recommendation to close the two elementary schools and one middle school, all in Fayetteville, and to open Rivers would save $1.6 million. The closures of Brooks and Tyrone would generate another $800,000 each. Beyond that, Key and Todd suggest that closing Inman, consolidating Fayetteville Intermediate and Hood Avenue and not opening Rivers would save a total of $4.8 million.

Even if all those were done the school board will still be faced with millions more in cuts in order to balance the 2013-2014 budget next June.

Though the school system is the largest tax levying entity in the county and receives nearly two-thirds of every local tax dollar collected, Fayette County, like other public school systems, holds the superintendent more like a CEO who makes recommendations that the board either accepts or rejects.

Unlike the operation of city councils or county commissions, school boards — including the Fayette County Board of Education — customarily make motions on voting items based on whether “to accept the superintendent’s recommendation.”

Todd in earlier comments said that, by state law, a school superintendent is responsible to the school board for the successful operation of the school system.

“That’s his one and only responsibility,” Todd said. “It’s the school board’s responsibility through policy to set their expectations for the superintendent to fulfill his or her responsibilities. Under Georgia law a school board is responsible for the operations of the school system, not the superintendent. For years a superintendent was elected in Georgia. That changed in the 1990s, yet school systems operate like the law never changed.”

But Key and Todd in the letter maintain that the school board must assert its responsibility.

“The Fayette County Board of Education is a corporate body which is tasked with being a good steward of the resources entrusted to us by the community. As such, individual board members are responsible for the financial well being of the district,” the letter said. “Board members have the authority to accept, modify and or reject recommendations of the superintendent in financial matters. They may also submit alternate recommendations to the board for consideration. We do not feel that the administration’s last two years of budget preparation, planning, and oversight has allowed board members to fulfill their fiduciary responsibilities to the tax-payers of this county. It also further weakens our ability to maintain a financially viable and quality school district.”

Key and Todd in the letter asked for the participation of school system employees and the community in the coming weeks as the discussions to close or consolidate schools is undertaken.

BrianAnderson
BrianAnderson's picture
Offline
Joined: 05/09/2009
FCBOE Bickering - Embarrassing Us All

I'm not a regular member of the blogging community here, but feel compelled to post after reading the continued negative commentary on Bearden and his job performance.

First - this is my first post on the Citizen. This is my real name. I'm a concerned Fayette county parent of 4 children, 2 of which are at Peachtree City Elementary and the oldest is a 6th grade student. I do not work for the school, nor does my wife or any of my family. I'm a technology entrepreneur and small business owner.

I volunteered this past year to represent my children's elementary school on a Community Advisory Board organized by Dr. Bearden. There was 1 representative from each school in the county. As a result of the 6-8 meetings I was fortunate enough to participate in, I was able to learn much about Dr. Bearden, his vision for our schools, and the mess he inherited. The best thing you as a board have done in my opinion is hiring Dr. Bearden. I commend you for making what was probably a tough decision at the time.

His plan of action for taking our school system to the next level was clearly spelled out to all of us. He was very open and honest with the entire group about the need to make very tough decisions, which included schools being closed. I know that each of the board attended at least one of these meetings, with Mr. Pressberg at multiple meetings. I'm sure you as a collective group either agreed with or disagreed with his strategy.

As for myself, I find Dr. Bearden to be an effective administrator and espousing a clear vision for where we need to go from an education standpoint. I'm a big fan, and hope that you and the entire Board can work with him to improve our system and help us recover from the current financial crisis.

To Board Members Key and Todd --

1. If you are grading the Superintendent a "fiscal F" -- why did you along with the remaining board members vote to extend his contract? If I remember correctly, the Citizen reported that his new contract was UNANIMOUSLY supported. On that note - why did he need a new contract so soon into his existing contract?

2. Please stop this grandstanding through the Citizen paper as a vehicle to either attack the Superintendent or your fellow board members.

If you find Dr. Bearden's (or the other board members) financial leadership lacking, address that to him directly either in person or at a public BOE meeting. While these negative comments in the newspaper make for good headlines -- that's all it is. In the end, they undermine your credibility in your constituents eyes.

I continually read and hear positive comments about you both as leaders and effective stewards of our schools, but after reading your Letter to the Editor and watching the back and forth public bickering, I'm left with a uneasy feeling. This type of "politics" does both yourselves and the Fayette county school system - teachers, staff, parents, and students, a disservice.

I value the school system. I think most of Fayette county feels the same way. It's one of the main reasons I moved here in 2000. I want each of you to do a phenomenal job leading our schools. I ask you both to work hard to not let our Board of Education go the way of the Fayette County Commission and Peachtree City Council and bring shame on our community.

Veritas
Veritas's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/23/2010
Mr. Anderson

Mr. Anderson in response to your questions to Dr.Todd and Mrs.Key.. 
Why the unanimous vote to extend Bearden's contract... (To keep the focus on the budget and financial issues not the Superintendent.)
" - why did he need a new contract so soon into his existing contract" 
He didn't. Usually the Superintendent and possibly outgoing board members do it out of concern for what a new board would do with his contract which would have expired December 31, 2013. This push came from Smith,Smola and Presberg .

2. Political grandstanding... Really now how many  board meetings have you attended.? Only a handful of citizens attend and very few employees. This type of letter is to keep the public informed as to what is really happening in the system. The letter directly addresses issues that have been discussed  in public and can be heard on Board Pod Casts Give back the final 2.5% pay reduction (Todd and Key voted no)
Repeated public requests for early recommended budget reductions for Fy 13, and now school closings that do not significantly reduce costs.  Once again how many Board meetings have you attended? Few if any I'm sure because if you had you would know this. 

As for attacks on fellow board members... Where do you see that ? 
I see no names but I do see facts placed on the  table for the public to see. But if you would like to talk of shame and embarrassment . I will be more than happy to provide links to who attacks whom.

The only named attacks I see come from the blogs/ citizens themselves not from  the board members.  Your opinion is your opinion but try and use fact on which to base it.
So,
 If really want to know the background and what has been going on... Go back to 1998 -2000 and research. The issue is most of you have been involved or cared enough to have a clue..  Most of you  run around parroting what someone TOLD you. Research , educate yourself and become informed.

http://www.thecitizen.com/articles/02-09-2010/students-16-school-budget-68

http://www.thecitizen.com/articles/03-23-2010/school-board-members-smith...

http://www.thecitizen.com/articles/07-06-2010/gop-race-school-board-anti...
 

http://www.thecitizen.com/articles/05-11-2010/todd-‘appalled’-smith-smola-attacks-boe

http://www.thecitizen.com/archive/main/archive-000216/news/fp-02.html

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=seNl0_rKXYE

These are a few resources to get you started.., now the rest is up to you!
Please remember  newspapers write the titles and head lines for articles, not the letter writers themselves. No where does the letter mention anyone giving anything a grade. 

americanpatriots
americanpatriots's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/05/2010
Why are we paving parking lots that don't need it

Because we have a school superintendent that lacks the leadership skills required for the job. In my opinion, he is in way over his head.

G35 Dude
G35 Dude's picture
Offline
Joined: 02/15/2006
Help me understand

With the BOE being in such dire straights that they are cutting employees, their pay, and asking for employees to pay more for benefits I have to ask a question. Why are we repaving school parking lots that didn't need it?