F’ville, Fayette weigh pros, cons of city water system sale

City’s gain: No fire department expenses

The possible merger of the Fayetteville and Fayette County fire departments is still being evaluated, but in the financial aspect, it may be just what the doctor ordered for the county’s ailing fire budget, which is funded exclusively by property taxes.

The county provides fire services for unincorporated Fayette County, Brooks, Woolsey and Tyrone. As such, the only ones chipping in to the county’s fire property tax live in those jurisdictions, as Fayetteville and Peachtree City operate their own fire departments.

But if the county were to absorb the city’s fire department, the county would be able to assess the fire property tax on all properties in the city of Fayetteville, including residential, commercial and industrial development.

It is those last two categories, commercial and industrial development, that are lacking in the unincorporated county, Brooks and Woolsey, county officials said. Over the past handful of years, and particularly as the economic times have slid downhill, so has the revenue from the county’s fire tax.

For this coming fiscal year, the fire fund revenues are down 12.7 percent, leaving the likelihood that property owners who pay a fire tax may face a property tax increase this year, particularly since the fire fund is not covering administrative costs nor is it contributing to the county’s vehicle replacement fund.

County Administrator Jack Krakeel told the Fayette County Commission last week that the ability to diversify the properties assessed for the fire tax is one of the main potential benefits to the county should a merger be pursued.

The county is working on a plan to take on the city’s fire department employees, but it will be able to save some funds by not needing to hire a temporary training officer as the city has done in recent years. That’s because the county already has its own training officials, Krakeel said.

The county is evaluating how shifting the employees from the city to the county would affect the county’s employee pension fund, Krakeel told the commission.

One complication to the process is the city’s use of a federal grant program in recent years to hire additional firefighters. Because of that grant, the city is forbidden to reduce its fire force even by one position, Krakeel noted.

When that restriction expires in the next few years, the city’s fire ranks could once again be reduced in some way, Krakeel noted.

Other fiscal benefits to the potential deal include the possibility of using the city’s impact fee fund to replace the city’s aging fire truck and also the ability to assume operations of the city’s fire station at Ga. Highway 85 and Johnson Avenue, Krakeel said.

The county is still working on getting a value of the city’s various firefighting equipment from turnout gear to its large vehicles, Krakeel said.

Krakeel said it will take at least into June to determine whether or not the merger is workable and in the best interests of the county. But when the recommendation comes, it will have two pieces to it. How to handle a consolidation of the departments and what the options are if that is not workable.

For Fayetteville residents, the main benefit of the merger is they will no longer be on the hook to operate the city fire department. Whether that will translate into an actual tax decrease remains to be seen.

The county fire department currently assists Fayetteville firemen on calls, but the county also provides EMS service to the entire city of Fayetteville. The city has no EMS of its own.

County’s gain: Fire tax, water revenue

The Fayette County Commission has agreed to share the cost of an assessment of the city of Fayetteville’s water system in advance of the county considering a possible purchase of the city-owned system.

It will cost the county about $7,500 for the study. Initially, the city approached the county several months ago about the possibility of merging the departments.

It turns out, however, that due to the city’s existing water and sewer bonds, the only way to make such a deal happen would be for the county to purchase the Fayetteville water system at a level to satisfy the bonds, county officials said.

The main benefit to the county would be the gain in water system customers, according to County Attorney Scott Bennett. But the Fayetteville system needs to be assessed to make sure there aren’t any outstanding or upcoming significant obligations for infrastructure repair or replacement, Bennett added.

“... This has to be self-sufficient enough,” Bennett said. “If we can’t generate enough revenues, we are not going to buy it.”

Commissioner Lee Hearn asked if the county would have to upgrade the city water meters if the change was made, and that was confirmed by County Administrator Jack Krakeel.

“If it’s a good business arrangement for the county to make more money, then let’s do that,” said Commission Chairman Herb Frady. “I don’t want us to do it at all if it will cost us money.”

Commissioner Steve Brown asked if a special “utility district” could be set up to raise rates on city water customers in the future to recover unforeseen costs and “make sure the county utility is not losing out on this deal.”

Bennett said that could be difficult, and if the county couldn’t offer the same rates for all users, he didn’t think the county would want to buy the system.

The plan is to shut down the city’s water production plant and instead use the county’s drinking water treatment plants instead, Bennett said.

The city would retain ownership and operation of its sewage treatment system and plant and presumably would continue billing Fayetteville customers for sewer service.

what's happening
what's happening's picture
Offline
Joined: 04/30/2012
Ffd

Its about time Fayetteville got smart and quit wasting the citizens money on a fire department that truly only provides fire service not medical. We are paying to send a truck out on a call only to turn around and come back to the station. They don't ride in the ambulance if the ambulance needs extra hands the county will need a manpower unit. Half the time the fire truck doesn't even go to medical calls in the city. They just cancel before even leaving the station. So why not just go ahead and let the county do it all.

whynot
whynot's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/27/2006
one sided story

John wrote an article after only interviewing the county manager who is retiring this year and apparently didn't interview the city manager whos goal is to only maintain his job. Well here are some factually information that wasn't disclosed in this article. The Fayetteville Fire Dept. has its own medical director and has held its State of Georgia first responder Ems license for 5 years. The aging equipment that Jack wants to replace is a tower ladder that only has 10K miles on it and is in excellent condition (per their appraisal company). The impact fees they want to use to replace this cannot be used for truck replacement, only for new infrastructure (new equipment). The last thing I am going to say is, how is the burden of running the Fayetteville Fire Dept. Going to be taken off the city tax payers if they have to pay a tax increase next year that will help fund the counties poor fire protection in south fayette county which had its ISO rating lowered this year! Big mistake if the citizens and businesses of Fayetteville allow these "good ole boys" to take over.

cstanley27
cstanley27's picture
Offline
Joined: 07/14/2009
The City of Fayetteville has no EMS of its own.

I am a child of Fayetteville; I grew up on Bates Avenue. My dad and some of his good friends were all volunteers at the City of Fayetteville Fire Department prior to Fayette County having an Emergency Service. Let me list some names: CJ Mowell, Russell Edmondson, Gwen Looney, Jerry Earnest, Lanett White, Brenda Stanley, Bobby Banks, Rick Stanley, and Alvin Huddleston. Now ask them if Fayetteville Fire has ever provided emergency medical services to the citizens of Fayetteville and Fayette County. My Aunt and next-door neighbor were in the first City EMT class in 1977 or 1978. I have a picture of them in the newspaper.

As for now, the City of Fayetteville Fire Department has required EMT’s or Emergency Medical Technicians since 2006. To be exact the service is BLS or Basic Life Support and it requires a state license (This is why a fire truck is provided by the City to major emergencies in the City and County). Therefore, to be accurate there has been a firefighter with an EMT license or First Responder helping protect City and County residents since 1976 give or take a year or two.

It would be correct in saying the citizens of Fayetteville have a contract with Fayette County Fire and EMS to provide ambulance transportation to its residents. It would be incorrect in saying and I quote the Citizen, “The city has no EMS of its own”.