A McIntosh junior decides to ditch GaGa

This morning, I decided to surf iTunes in search of some new, upbeat music to add to my beaten and shorted iPod Nano, so I quickly browsed the top download section in case there was something new or interesting, and quickly I noticed that Lady GaGa was, once again, the top single on iTunes. I became wary the instant I saw the title name: “Judas.”

Six months ago, I was an avid Lady GaGa fan. Her music was catchy, her style was extremely unique, and her lyrics were, well, provocative to say the least, but overlookable. My iPod was loaded with songs like “Just Dance,” “Love Game,” “Telephone,” “Poker Face,” “Alejandro,” and “Bad Romance.” What a fresh, new pop icon!

Her music videos were definitely strange, but I assumed that was her style, and it wasn’t harming anyone. My first shock truly came from her “Alejandro” music video. This disturbing video portrayed her in a sinister, sexual, satanic way that honestly made my spine crawl as I watched her half-naked with a leash tied around a man, completely missing what I thought the message of the song was. If I was so off-base, what is she metaphorically singing about?

My faith in GaGa hit rock bottom after hearing “Born This Way” and watching the accompanying music video. The hypocrisy is outrageous. Here she is, preaching that everyone was born a certain way while I am watching a starved body in her underwear with bleached blonde hair and covered in make-up interlaced with vulgar images of women’s ovaries.

I refused to listen to the song any longer. Not only because of the cheap lyrics and the hypocrisy of GaGa, but also from its play off of one of my favorite artists: Madonna.

So, this morning, with extreme caution, I clicked on her new single “Judas,” and was completely blown away. Such satanic propaganda being at the top of the iTunes charts honestly hurt my heart as to what Americans were supporting.

By buying and supporting this song, America is supporting the recitation of lyrics such as “I’m in love with Judas” and other lines relating the downfall of Jesus by adults, teens, and even children listening to this song on the radio, where I am sure it will soon appear.

Even if it is a metaphor for the betrayal of a man and not literally Judas, this idea is not apparent from her lyrics. Also, a less offensive metaphor would have suited just fine if that was really the idea she was trying to portray, but then that wouldn’t be as shocking and she might even make a little less money.

In an effort to extract more income out of her off-beat style, she has moved from a shocking artist to a fabricated fraud, pretending to be reaching new heights of artistic self-expression. I no longer find her believable.

It appears more and more to be a manufactured production, without compromise or consideration, with the sole purpose of “one-upping” the previous attempt and getting those shock-value sales.

Well, it worked. I have started this day shocked and disturbed. I am shocked by the offensive material that Lady GaGa consistently now pushes into our path and disturbed by the amount of support “Judas” has received from America.

The more support this type of music receives, the more music of this genre will be put on the radios; the lyrics and message will soon be ingrained in the hearts and minds of its listeners.

Maybe one day there will be no new plateau to reach in offending Christians and we can move on to offending some other group for more shock value and more money.

Personally, I have decided to no longer support Lady GaGa music, in hopes that others will do the same to stop the absurdity. If society deems this song to be acceptable, how truly low has America’s morality bar been set? Is our moral compass so warped that we select our musical entertainment by shock value and interesting beats alone with no regard whatsoever for the message?

Mine’s not. Is yours?

Rachel Pullias

Peachtree City, Ga.

[Rachel is a junior at McIntosh High School.]

normal
normal's picture
Offline
Joined: 08/11/2009
Rachel

If society deems this song to be acceptable, how truly low has America’s morality bar been set?

Americas morality bar has been set by Bill Clinton. Anything goes under the table in the oval office.

So you see every generation has its little problems and we all move on.

roundabout
roundabout's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/01/2011
Rachel and Madonna and GAGA

I am puzzled that Madonna is your hero but not GaGa!

There seems to be no difference in their methods to me.

Have you seen Madonna's book "Sex?" Wonderful stuff!

I'm afraid nearly all current music and morality have nothing in common. even many of the "Christian" musicians are faking it to sell to you.

You don't need these people, or their music, to be moral in your life.

I'm afraid my vision of a moral person is some monk in a monastery who doesn't speak or listen much, but works hard daylight til dark! That is when he is not on his face, prostate.

All others are pretenders, part-time. You do write well--I hope it was all yours.

hutch866
hutch866's picture
Offline
Joined: 12/28/2005
roundabouta$

This child never said Madonna was her hero, but just a favorite. But of course spin it in a negative way, after all that's all you have.

roundabout
roundabout's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/01/2011
hutch

You amaze me! Madonna is her favorite but not her hero? Sure she is!

That is like saying that I-phones are their favorite but not their hero.

Pastor or Bishop Long is my favorite preacher but not my hero!

As to whether this "child" as you say, wrote all of this alone and not proof-read is not important, it is just that EVERY paragraph or page that I have read by a teen-ager in recent years is a sad tale of learning and teaching.

Of course all my children and all of my friend's children are perfect! All of PTC children score ABOVE average against every other child in PTC!

I can have my doubts and not be "negative" as you said.

MYTMITE
MYTMITE's picture
Offline
Joined: 02/14/2008
Er, Round do you mean prostrate---I don't his face has a

prostate.

Ninja Guy
Ninja Guy's picture
Offline
Joined: 06/26/2010
Roundy, I Hope You Meant

prostrate, and not prostate! Or, maybe you were making a play on words concerning certain aspects of the monastic life! Or, maybe you are at the stage of life where the latter is more of a concern to you than the former!

If the writing is not all Rachel's, I trust OOFU and Bacon will sniff out any plagiary and swoop down on her like T-garlock locking in on a VC in a rice paddy!

I like Madonna's Like A Prayer Video more than her Sex book!

I think Madonna said it best when she said,

'Straight men need to be emasculated. I'm sorry. They all need to be slapped around. Women have been kept down for too long. Every straight guy should have a man's tongue in his mouth at least once.'

(taken from http://womenshistory.about.com)

Swift Death To the Confused Moral Writings of High-School Juniors and Equally Confused Replies by Vietnam Vets!

Go Braves! Bats finally coming alive--I hope!

MYTMITE
MYTMITE's picture
Offline
Joined: 02/14/2008
I guess i miss something---

Is someone saying they young lady could not have written the letter? I know many teens who could have written that letter, so I didn't question it's authenticity--is there some doubt?

Spyglass
Spyglass's picture
Offline
Joined: 01/28/2008
This is ALL I know about Lady Gaga...Christopher Walken
tgarlock
tgarlock's picture
Offline
Joined: 10/26/2005
Rachel, you are thoughtful and . . .

. . . a talented writer to boot. But what I like most are the values that prompted your letter to the editor. Each of us has to decide for ourselves what lines may not be crossed and our line says a lot about us. I hope there are many like you at McIntosh High School where my daughter will be going next year. Your parents must be bursting proud of you, I know I am.

Recent Comments